Pollak: "Pro-choice groups have wasted no
time in launching vicious--and false--attacks against Rep. Paul Ryan
after Republican presidential contender Mitt Romney selected him as his
running mate for the November election. In a NARAL press release being
circulated by Democrats and women’s groups, the Catholic, pro-life Ryan
is accused of “extreme” anti-abortion views. NARAL isn’t simply content
to disagree with Ryan’s views; it resorts to lying about Ryan--and about
much else besides. For example, one of the lies told by Nancy Keenan,
president of NARAL Pro-Choice America, is that Ryan “supported the ‘Let
Women Die Bill,’ which would allow hospitals to refuse to provide a
woman emergency, lifesaving abortion care, even if she could die without
it.” It goes without saying that there was never any such piece of
legislation. The actual bill to which Keenan is referring was called the
“Protect Life Act,” H.R. 358, and it is about protecting religious
freedom, not banning abortion. The act was passed in response to
concerns that the Obama administration would force Catholic hospitals
(and others) to provide abortions. Keenan makes it seem as though Ryan
had voted to ban abortion at all hospitals, even if the mother’s life
was in mortal danger. He did not. (Update: It is worth noting--since
Keenan does not--what Ryan's position on abortion actually is: he has
always opposed it, except in cases where the mother's life is in
danger--precisely what Keenan tries to lie about. The Associated Press
noted as far back as 1998, during Ryan's first run for Congress, that
"Republican nominee Paul Ryan has opposed abortion in general except to
save a woman's life.") She continues with a torrent of lies, such as
that Ryan’s record includes “Repeatedly voting to deny women in the
military – who defend our freedom overseas – the right to use their own,
private funds for abortion care at military hospitals.” Again, what
Keenan leaves out is critical: no U.S. military hospitals provide
abortions to begin with. And the culmination of Keenan’s diatribe:
“Romney has pledged that taking away women’s rights will be a priority
for him and his choice of Ryan amplifies that promise to the extreme
anti-choice backers of this ticket.” He has done no such thing--any more
than Barack Obama has vowed to slaughter millions of innocent babies,
though that is the least charitable way of putting his position.
Pro-choice advocates are apparently so afraid of dissent that they must
demonize their opponents as woman-haters. And the mainstream media--such
as Politico, which quoted Keenan's press release uncritically, lies and
all--enables their smears. If you want to understand Ryan's strong
pro-life views, you can read them for yourself, and decide. But
pro-choice groups would rather smear than debate."